Instead of soccer players getting sent off, should another player be added to the opposing team?

Currently, if a player gets two yellow cards (or a red), he gets sent off. Wouldn't it be more entertaining if, instead of a player leaving the pitch, one was added to the opposing side, with no limit on the players allowed on the pitch. If a team ran out of players to field, the fans could start taking part. Am I right, or am I right?

Answers:
no no no. maybe it'd be exciting for you, but for me, it would take the purpose out of the game. a game needs a structure and rules. the player needs limits so they can have something to work for. a game without structure and rules would be less meaningful and it would require less effort from both sides to score goals and what not. in other words, a game without structure and rules would be mad chaos.
Yes they should do that.
no take the goal keeper off
Yeah right. One side has 50 players and the other side 11. Silly idea, won't ever work.
i love it,
lets get FIFA on board and let the party begin.
Award the opposing team a goal.?
Ha ha, i like that

Mind you, with the way Sheffield United are playing at the moment, they could have 50 players on the pitch and they'd still lose 3-nil.
And make the goals the whole breadth of the pitch and let people use horses. Cut the goalkeepers legs off, make the ball the size of a sofa and let monkeys be the referee. All just as viable as your ludicrous idea. There is not enough space on a football pitch for creativity as it is. Also, someone committing a red card or two yellow card offences need to be punished, and staying on the pitch doesn't do that.
that is not promise in rules or you change rules
There would be way too many players on the field including the referee all in total would be 23. It would be chaos in there.
its a nice idea but really you need to punish to prevent. minus a point for a red card, after all you effectively tried to cheat !
Never and its football....
It would certainly add intrest but the game would become mad!
No. You are very wrong.
go to bed you are rubbish at being alive
And they will end up playing 20 a side.
Nah, the rules are rules for a reason. They must have passed stringent thought before being issued by the committee. I think the current rule is just fine.
NO

The answers post by the user, for information only, UKQnA.com does not guarantee the right.

  • is it normal to be nervouse before a rugby match?
  • Why do liverpool keep buying has bin strikers?
  • why can't goalkeepers wear head-helmet ??
  • what is a cannalure?
  • Watching Football(soccer) in America?
  • Matt Hardy?
  • do you think wales has a chance to win the next wourld cup?
  • who is better ronaldhinio or theirry henry?
  • does anybody have some world cup 2006 stickers for sale??